What a home in Garden City sells for, and how long it takes
What the recorded deeds say, how long a sale takes where OneKey® MLS measures it, and what a seller pays at closing. Every figure on this page names its source.
Recorded deeds put the median sale in Garden City at $1,366,250, across 120 arm's-length sales in the rolling 12 months ended September 2, 2026, and OneKey® MLS measures a typical 17 days from listing to contract.
- Recorded sales
- 120
- Median price
- $1,366,250
- Middle half of prices
- $1,157,500 to $1,743,750
Recorded deeds, rolling 12 months ended September 2, 2026, 120 arm's-length sales.
- Days on market
- 17median, listing to contract
- Months of supply
- 1.5inventory at the current pace
- Of original list
- 101.0%median share of the first asking price
OneKey® MLS, Garden City, as of July 2026.
- New York State transfer tax
- 0.4%$2 for every $500 of the sale price
Rates as of September 2026; your attorney confirms the figures at contract.
A buyer in Garden City is not subject to the pied-à-terre surcharge that applies in New York City or the Peconic Bay transfer taxes that apply on the East End. Financing, timing and how the property is positioned matter more here than any added tax at the closing table.
Pricing at this level starts with evidence, not a guess, and a private second opinion before the property is offered.
Not ready for a conversation? Watch it instead.
Tell us the address and we will send you, once a month, where the home stands against recorded sales nearby. Nothing public, nothing owed, and a person one reply away when the time comes.
Questions Worth Asking
Tell us what you are weighing
You will get a candid view of the position before anyone asks you for a commitment.