What a home in Sag Harbor sells for, and how long it takes
What the recorded deeds say, how long a sale takes where OneKey® MLS measures it, and what a seller pays at closing. Every figure on this page names its source.
Recorded deeds put the median sale in Sag Harbor at $2,500,000, across 137 arm's-length sales in the rolling 12 months ended September 2, 2026, and OneKey® MLS measures a typical 125 days from listing to contract.
- Recorded sales
- 137
- Median price
- $2,500,000
- Middle half of prices
- $1,700,000 to $4,400,000
- Median price per sq ft
- $1,175
Recorded deeds, rolling 12 months ended September 2, 2026, 137 arm's-length sales.
- Days on market
- 125median, listing to contract
- Months of supply
- 9.6inventory at the current pace
- Of original list
- 89.7%median share of the first asking price
OneKey® MLS, Sag Harbor, as of July 2026.
- New York State transfer tax
- 0.4%$2 for every $500 of the sale price
Rates as of September 2026; your attorney confirms the figures at contract.
A buyer here also pays the Peconic Bay Region Community Preservation Fund, 2% of the price, and the Community Housing Fund, 0.5% on top of it. Both are buyer-side charges that appear on the buyer's own closing statement, not yours.
Rates as of September 2026; your attorney confirms the figures at contract.
Pricing at this level starts with evidence, not a guess, and a private second opinion before the property is offered.
Not ready for a conversation? Watch it instead.
Tell us the address and we will send you, once a month, where the home stands against recorded sales nearby. Nothing public, nothing owed, and a person one reply away when the time comes.
Questions Worth Asking
Tell us what you are weighing
You will get a candid view of the position before anyone asks you for a commitment.